Ronnie at his "best" would've defeated Phil, but I do believe Phil would've defeated Ronnie on his bad years, of which there were a few, particularly in 2002, when a leg-less Kevrone should've defeated a flat and relatively smallish' 246 lb, 6 foot Ronnie. Phil weighed the same as Ronnie did that year (at 3 inches shorter)...AND Phil's condition was superior to Ronnie's in 02'. I think you're mkaing a mistake if you think any version of Ronnie would've handed Phil his ass. Not happeneing. Only Ronnie's best years would've convincingly beaten Phil.
It is funny to me that you're actually irritated that I am praising Phil, especially when it is rightfully due. Sorry of that bothers you, but I love BB'ing and the Mr.Olympia is my favorite time of the year. I don't beloeve any compliments I've given Phil were undeserved.